There is a famous quotation attributed to the ancient Greek philosopher, Aristotle:
“We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act but a habit.”
As it turns out, Aristotle never said these exact words. In 1926, author Will Durant gave this as a quasi-modernised summation of elements of Aristotle’s teachings.
But whether or not Aristotle said these exact words, this sentiment is very much rooted in his philosophies of actions, habits and virtue.
Many pedagogues and coaches cite this quotation to inspire people to practice, to knuckle down, to cultivate a habit of excellence. I have done and will continue to do the same. Such a message focuses on the second clause of this quote.
But there’s something wonderfully insightful in the first clause also, that we can often miss, especially as it pertains to the very on-trend topic of labels and identity.
“We are what we repeatedly do”.
The Problem with ‘Identity’
I bring this up, because I’ve recently had a lot of conversations – within the context of music and outside of it as well – about identity, especially when it comes to creating labels for oneself.
Worry not, we’re not going into the weeds on this. It’s a huge topic, with many facets, each with far more nuance, psychology and depth than I could possibly bring justice to. Instead, everything that follows is said within the context of voice.
Singers, like every human on earth, want to feel like they have a handle on who they are and what they should be doing – in our case, vocally speaking. They want to figure out who they are, what their voice is capable of, what they are good at, and cultivate artistry.
WHile this is a great goal, this tends to manifest in overly definitive, declarative statements beginning with “I am
As such, often these labels are initially inaccurate, as less experienced singers frantically try to firm up a complete vocal identity for themselves. Labels are also static, whilst we as people are dynamic. We are never just one thing, and no one label ever sums us up fairly, accurately or completely.
Herein lies the danger I want to highlight for you: the danger of clinging so tightly to some label or immutable ‘identity’, such that it one cannot let go of this identity even when it doesn’t fit where one is at.
This can inhibit development massively, but even worse, it can be a huge source of unresolveable anxiety to the singer, especially when events in reality don’t marry up with some internally held standard. Let me share a few examples. Continue reading “The Danger of Labelling Yourself as One Thing or Another”