Sensory Confusion: How it feels, vs how it sounds for singers

To illustrate this topic of sensory confusion in singers, I want to reference a story I read a few years ago.

Braille readers

Blind people read using Braille – a system of raised dots to indicate letters and words. They do this using the tips of their index, middle and ring fingers. Their brains and bodies become more and more attuned to those tiny surface markings to interpret them as data to form words and meaning. Like normal reading, the brain has to sense individuals letters, then chunk them together to form words, then sentences. The faster one can sense and interpret these markings, the faster one can read.

The plasticity of the brain enables this. What this means is that as the Braille readers feed their brain data from their fingers, that the parts of the brain linked to interpreting sensory experiences from the fingers grows and becomes more developed. The more advanced and experienced the Braille reader, the more developed and complex that region of the brain becomes.

Here’s where it get interesting

Researchers did an experiment on a group of Braille readers, where they essentially poked the ends of the readers index, middle and ring fingers. What they found was this: the Braille readers would not always be able to identify, or even misidentify which finger was being prodded, i.e. you prodded their index finger, but to them it could easily be one of the others. Continue reading “Sensory Confusion: How it feels, vs how it sounds for singers”

Vocal Quality: Developing and Respecting Vocal Headroom

I’ve talked before about this idea of vocal tessitura. This is a very nuanced concept, so please have a read of that article. This week I wanted to talk about vocal headroom.

Here is the summarised definition of tessitura from that other article:

Tessitura asks “how comfortable are you” in certain regions of your voice, and where should we place songs so that:
a) the melody of a song is in the best spot in your voice; and
b) the opportunity to style and riff/ornament above that melody is still open to you (while still remaining comfortable).

What is vocal headroom?

Let’s start with this definition of tessitura. While reading it, let’s also think about how this can apply to us as we are figuring out a song.

Tessitura instructs us to optimise the key of a song such that you:
a) sound great on the original melody in that key without straining, and yet also
b) have melodic space above that original melody such that you can extrapolate or ornament the original melody as you see fit.

The emboldened elements outline the key take-aways for identifying and respecting your own vocal headroom. Continue reading “Vocal Quality: Developing and Respecting Vocal Headroom”

Why certain singing questions SEEM important, but aren’t

If any of you have studied anything to a high level, you’ll know just how deceptively complex almost any given subject can be. This seems self-evident for subjects like quantum physics, philosophy, economics, brain surgery, microcomputers, etc. Even their subject titles require some explanation to most lay-people, and almost every word used within that subject requires deep understanding and definitions to put everything together.

The Learning Paradigm

With such subjects, we enter into a mental paradigm where we accept that complete knowledge of all elements is not possible. This paradigm directs helps us appreciate the vastness and nuance of the subject, and directs our learning. It also typically keeps us humble and always open to further insight.

Viewing subjects in this way usually helps us see the multi-faceted nature of such subjects, and not to assume anything. This further helps us to grasp that we need to study from experts, undergo apprenticeships, and spend many years in training to acquire requisite skills to get our understanding right.

One key thing to note: in such subjects we accept that often what may initially seem like an obvious and sensible question to ask, may in fact reveal a thought process that shows one does not (and sometimes cannot!) fully grasp the nuances of the subject at hand. Continue reading “Why certain singing questions SEEM important, but aren’t”

Vocal Aesthetic: Find Singers That Reflect YOUR Voice

I once wrote an article called 5 Reasons: Why singing is like clothing…. While the article is not especially the most read article on my site, it is (in my opinion) one of the most relevant and important articles I’ve written for understanding your own voice. This topic is critically overlooked by far too many singers.

When it comes to building your voice to be capable of whatever you throw at it, having an appropriate ‘vocal aesthetic’ in mind is crucial. This is to both build your voice to be the best it can be (now and in the future), and also to minimise otherwise avoidable frustration. It’s this topic that I want to revisit this week.

Why ONLY looking at range can lead you down a dead-end

As it happens, I was working with a particular client this week. They have a great voice, and they brought in a selection of songs to look at towards the end of their session.

Now, every single one of the songs they had brought in, was well within their range and existing style capacity. Even just based on where we were taking their voice during vocal exercises, the melodies of the songs were less demanding in their range. So the natural question most would ask is, which song did we pick?

Answer: None of them

We looked at another singer entirely, one we had discussed and tried previously, but a different one altogether. But why? Continue reading “Vocal Aesthetic: Find Singers That Reflect YOUR Voice”

What makes a song “feel high”?

This topic has been coming up a lot recently, and also came up in yesterdays voice intensive, so I wanted to talk about it this week. As an aside, I’ve been trying to write this article for several months. It’s a difficult and somewhat abstract/subjective topic to discuss.

What makes a song “feel high”?

If you’ve EVER tried to sing a song that seems like it’s at the limits of your capacity, or beyond, you’ve experienced that sensation of “that song feels high“… but if we get ‘reductionist’ on this statement, what do we really mean?

The idea of a song feeling high/too high can actually be viewed as multiple issues wrapped up in one: Continue reading “What makes a song “feel high”?”

Vocal Pedagogy: Why we need to look to the past to progress into the future

A great coach once said to me “to be a student of singing, you must be a student of the HISTORY of singing”.

My first reaction wasn’t necessarily positive

At first hearing of this, I was initially dismissive to some extent – why does it matter what people 20, 50, 100+ years ago were doing? What does that even mean and why is the history of singing relevant to me and my voice? But pause for a second, and think more like a scientist, and you’ll begin to understand. Continue reading “Vocal Pedagogy: Why we need to look to the past to progress into the future”

Why can’t I sing as high as I used to? a.k.a. How a voice can go downhill

“Why can’t I sing as high as I used to?”

THIS is a question I get asked a lot. I’ve extensively covered the effects of aging on the voice in this article I previously wrote, but in this article I want to use some actual examples of voices that are golden voices in their own genres, but that have perhaps gone on to find their voices have gone downhill compared to their golden years.

It’s also helpful to hear these to realise that EVERYONE has their issues. I’m not picking on the following singers because I think they are bad (far from it!) but merely to remind us that they are human, and we all have peaks and troughs over time and day to day.

In each of these cases however, I’d put this down to issues in their technique that maybe weren’t backbreaking at age 20, but at age 30, 40, 50 or older become back-breaking technical issues for each of them.

The Allure of Youth

Note: It’s always easier to sing high and sound fresh when you’re young. This isn’t the primary sign of vocal ability, it’s a hallmark of youth. The challenge lies in building one’s voice so it gets stronger and fuller as you get older rather than getting run into the ground through bad habits and poor technique.

This is especially problematic when singers acquire commercial acclaim based on an unsustainable sound. Let’s go through a few examples I think show this issue well: Continue reading “Why can’t I sing as high as I used to? a.k.a. How a voice can go downhill”

Vocal Tessitura – What is it? How is this helpful?

What is vocal tessitura? This comes up a lot, with clients who are just starting to figure out their voice, all the way up to experienced professionals.

Wikipedia defines vocal tessitura as:

“… the most aesthetically acceptable and comfortable vocal range for a given singer”

While this is a factually correct summation, it overlooks critical context for the concept of tessitura. Let me explain.

Vocal tessitura vs. range?

When we talk about vocal range we typically only consider it’s extremes. E.g. “I can sing from this low note X, to this high note Y, so my range is X to Y“.

However, range alone fails to describe the quality across that range, how connected that range is, etc. Moreover, how comfortable is it for the singer to sing in any one spot? How long can the singer linger in the range in question?

It’s not just about top notes and bottom notes – it’s about your ability in-between

YouTube is littered with videos of “Freddie Mercury’s Vocal Range” or “Whitney Houston’s Vocal Range“. These videos typically piece together clips of every note on the keyboard that they ever sang, even if it’s only a high squeak or a low squawk (I’ve seen range clips that include such sounds as “vocal range examples”). To say this is their true vocal range is very generous and simply not representative of their true tessitura.

This does not show where they would choose to sing to give their best quality and singing experience. It is only an amalgamated record of notes they have hammered out on one song or another over their whole career, rather than identifying the range over which they sounded and felt at their best.

Range taken by itself simply cannot answer this question, but tessitura takes account of all of these factors.

Understanding your own vocal tessitura?

Tessitura asks “how comfortable are you” in certain regions of your voice. The core of it is asking a more holistic question regarding where should we place songs in one’s voice, such that:

a) the melody of a song is in the best spot in your voice, taking advantage of the different colours across the different registers in your voice; and
b) the opportunity to style and riff/ornament above that melody is still open to you, while still remaining comfortable.

To understand your own tessitura, you must not only know your range, but the comfortable zones within that range. Where are the sweet spots that you can sing in for extended periods, day in, day out? This means singing well without a hint of forcing, without a hint of damaging or straining your voice, no following tailwind to help you out, etc.

You also need to know what those different areas in your voice are useable for (e.g. where does the melody belong in your voice, where does the style portion sit, etc).

Yelled notes don’t count

Many men can sing/yell/blast out an A4, but that doesn’t mean they can comfortably sing most of Bono’s songs. These live between D4-A4. Most just don’t have the technique to spend all their time up there. Even Bono typically resorts to taking older material down at least a semitone these days.

Similarly, many female singers can sing all the notes in most of Michael Buble’s songs in their original keys, but that doesn’t mean they want to stick their voice in a place where it feels like it’s scraping along the ground. It’s generally just too low for most female singers. They can hit the notes, but it isn’t optimising the song for their voice. Songs for women (assuming they have the capacity to access their upper range without issue) generally need to be taken up several keys to place the song in a better spot for their voice.

Can we change our tessitura?

In short, yes. Through the right training you can absolutely change your tessitura.

I started out singing in a baritone range, and worked my way up bit by bit (taking years) to be comfortable as a high tenor. It’s not the range or power that takes time exactly, it’s to do it so it feels totally free and natural, and to create quality rather than just “merely” hitting the note. It’s not just about unlocking and accessing more notes, it’s about integrating them into your voice so seamlessly, that you forget it’s a new note at all. Many of my clients experience a similar thing, especially if their starting tessitura is very different to the material they want to sing. It just takes training.

However, if a note feels even slightly forced, or that you have to reach up (or down!) for the note, then it’s not integrated successfully. As such, even if we’ve unlocked extra range using particular vocal exercises, those notes will forever feel separate and distinct from one’s voice until they are integrated into the existing voice.

Songs can also be considered to have a requisite tessitura

Consider if we were to go through the melody and count how many times each note occurs, then display this as a graph. We’d end up with very different shape curves depending on the song. Some would have most of the range clustered low then one or two higher notes, others may have most of the range clustered high and the odd low notes, some might have clusters down low and clusters up high, etc. Consider this a “signature” of the required tessitura the song will demand of the singer.

Different voices (even with full training) will have different fully developed tessituras, and what their voices do well/less well. The more range and control you have, the more songs will be available to you, but that still doesn’t mean that you will be able to sing all songs equally well. The tessitura signature of different songs will match better to your voice than others. That’s why it is important to understand your own tessitura, and match it appropriately to both the right songs, and putting those songs in a key that maximises the match between your voice and the song.

Know your voice

I hope that helps you understand the idea of vocal tessitura a bit better. There really is no other way than to really get to grips with your voice as an instrument and understand where melodies and ornamentations belong, and install your voice into appropriate songs as such.

Mark JW Graham LogoWant our FREE 'Singing 101' Vocal Prospectus?